Skip to main content

Breast Pump Comparison - Which Insurance Pump Should I Choose?

Moms often ask - "Of the pumps that are offered free with my insurance plan, which pump is my best choice?"  This is a great question because there are several factors to consider when choosing a breast pump.

Most importantly, hygiene needs to be considered when choosing a breast pump.  Is this a pump that won't contaminate my breast milk?  The answer is in whether it has an open or closed system.  Closed system pumps protect your milk from having dust or bacteria blown into the bottles while you are pumping.  The biggest offender in this area are the Medela pumps.  They do not offer a closed system and the Medela company does not comply with the codes set up by the World Health Organization so it is easy to rule this brand out.

The next consideration is the function.  Is it a double electric auto-cycling breast pump with at least 250mmHG which is milligrams of mercury, a measurement commonly used in measuring strength of suction. Most commonly infants do 220mmHG when they suckle, but since breast pumps suction can depend on which type of power you are using and whether or not the valves and filters or diaphragms have been changed regularly, starting at 250mmHG gives you a little wiggle room.  Lansinoh breast pumps only do 220mmHG, so you can rule that one out as well.

Another big consideration is flange fitment.  Newer brands like Motif Medical only offer flanges in 24mm and 28mm size.  You will want a brand that offers at least four sizes ranging from 20mm to 32mm to find the size that works best for you.  In addition as I was doing research on the Motif brand, I noted that several of their replacement parts were out of stock on their website including the all important double pumping kit.  In addition, this brand is new on the scene so until more parts and information is available on this company, I would rule them out as well. Evenflo also does not offer a small flange size and not many parts are available individually without buying an entire double pumping kit.  I would rule out Evenflo because of this and because they are typically a bottle company so not as invested in your breastfeeding success as you would want them to be.

Ok, enough of the "don't choose this pump" warnings.  With 25 years experience 
in the breastfeeding industry, which pumps do we recommend?

#1 Choice - Spectra S2 Plus Breast Pump
Pros:  The Spectra pump has a two year warranty on the motor, does 250mmHG and offers a wide range of breast flange sizes and replacement part options.  We love the night light on the Spectra S2 Plus for exclusively pumping moms or for moms with babies in the NICU that have to pump at night. This pump offers a hygienic closed system using a backflow protector.  In addition, a Spectra breast pump parts subscription service for the most important and commonly replaced parts.  Cons:  Spectra company does not offer a combination cooler carrier tote bag or a car adapter for power, but there are great aftermarket options that cover those needs.


#2 Choice - Hygeia EnJoye Breast Pump
Pros:   Quality breast pump with a one year warranty that not only does 250mmHG, but also cycles up to 80 times per minute (the average baby does 60 sucks per minute).  Also offers a closed system with an apparelled bacteriostatic filter.  Cons:  Only three flanges sizes are available in this brand, but the flange connector does fit the Pumpin' Pal brand of angled Supershields, so smaller options can be obtained.  To see if your insurance qualifies you for the Hygeia EnJoye, visit the Hygeia website.


#3 Choice - Ameda Finesse
Pros:  Ameda has been the most consistently breastfeeding forward company since double electric breastpumps were invented 75 years ago by Einar Egnell who founded the company formerly known as Ameda Egnell.  While Ameda pumps do not offer the most whistles and bells on the market, they are consistently good and their quality control is apparelled.  They offer a two year warranty on the Ameda Finesse and offer flange sizes and inserts in a wide range of sizes including the Flexishield silicone insert that not only reduces to 22 mm, but is the best made silicone insert on the market today.  I have personally seen moms with smaller nipples get an ounce of extra milk with the Ameda flexishield.  Ameda was the first to offer a closed system with a diaphragm barrier to protect breast milk.  Cons:  Not as smooth or quiet as some other pumps, but definitely gets the job done!


#4 Choice ARDO Calypso
Pros:  Closed system double electric breast pump with a wide range of flange sizes from 22mm -31mm.  They have a one year warranty on the ARDO Calypso and are the only company to offer a insert in a 26mm size silicone flange insert called the Optiflow.  Considered quieter than the Ameda Finesse.  Cons: This pump is not as popular with moms as the top three choices.  I would only choose this one if the other three were not available.   Having sold breast pumps for 25 years, I can see the writing on the wall so while this pump may work well for you, I do not know how long this company will be around.


Power is also important!  All four of our recommendations: Spectra S2 Plus, Hygeia Enjoye, Ameda Finesse and ARDO Calypso have an AC adapter and either a branded or aftermarket car adapter available.  If you need battery power regularly, the Hygeia EnJoye LBI model is a good investment even if it not covered by insurance.  While most pumps include a battery compartment, don't rely on AA or AAA batteries for good suction if you can't plug in to an outlet or a car lighter as your pump will not have the same power and your milk supply will suffer. The Hygeia EnJoye LBI Breast Pump model with battery is not usually available through insurance as it is a more expensive model.

This review is for the breast pumps most frequently offered by insurance companies and includes information on Medela, Lansinoh, Motif Medical, Spectra, Hygeia, Ameda and ARDO.  If your insurance company offers another brand that you would like us to review, please include it in our comments section and we will update this review as needed.

Best wishes for the best milk expression!
Tanya










Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Breastfeeding Pain Diagnosis: Yeast Infection and Thrush

I would love to tell you that breastfeeding is always easy, but unfortunately that is not always the case.  When you look up the word tenacious (te·na·cious) in the dictionary, I picture the nursing mother who has been tried by the challenges that sometimes come with breastfeeding.

Today, I am addressing a challenge that literally tries a mom by fire, yeast infections.  Yeast on nipples often exhibits itself as a burning sensation and sharp shooting pains in the breast even in-between feedings.   If you have pain only during the feeding, you need to address the latch.  Yeast naturally occurs in our bodies, but the overgrowth of yeast often as a result of oral or IV antibiotics can be a real challenge.  The good news is that it is fairly easy to diagnose and curing the overgrowth is manageable, especially if you know how to avoid a recurring incidence.

Lets start with the diagnosis.  As I said, the mother with yeast will normally have burning sensation on her nipples and sharp shooting…

Feeding Expressed Breast Milk: Fresh vs. Frozen

Many moms are automatically freezing their breast milk each time they pump and retrieving frozen milk from their stockpile to feed the baby.  While this is ok for the mom who gives an occasional bottle, working moms should be giving freshly expressed milk whenever possible. 

     Before we list these factors, let us be clear than breast milk, fresh or frozen is immeasurably better for your infant nutritionally than formula; but to use the best at it's very best, we are explaining the changes that happen to frozen breast milk. 

     1.  Levels of pH are effected by freezing which in turn effects lipase which aids in digestion.  Lipase levels vary from woman to woman, so if you notice a soapy smell or metallic taste to your frozen breast milk, it may be especially relevant to you to give freshly expressed breast milk.

     2.  Bactericidal capacity of stored refrigerated human milk is at it's greatest within the first 48 to 72 hours of refrigeration.  (By the way, this is…

Breastfeeding Secrets Revealed: Position, Hold and Proper Latch

New moms have told me that they wish they had been given more information on positioning and latch as well as the various holds associated with breastfeeding.  So I have decided to reveal these breastfeeding "secrets" here. 
1.  What is the secret to preparing for breastfeeding?
Holding the breast properly!  The c-hold is the proper way to support the breast when learning to breastfeed and should be practiced by expectant and new mothers because almost every new mom does it incorrectly.  How?  Moms tend to place the thumb on top (correct) but place the bottom fingers in the wrong place.  The bottom fingers need to be near the chest wall.  The index finger usually ends up on the bottom of the areola preventing baby from getting a deep latch.  Whether you are already breastfeeding or still expecting, check your c-hold in a mirror to make sure your fingers are out of the way. Also make sure the flap of your nursing bra is not in the way.  Remember, a new baby cannot suppo…